FAQ

Below you find a selection of questions we have received regarding HEAT. If you can’t find yours feel free to email us at heatwalkingcycling@who.int.

Who can use HEAT?

Although HEAT was initially designed for transport practitioners, it can be used by a wide range of actors including (but not limited to) practitioners, community actors, government and city officials, NGO representatives, private sector agents, researchers, donors, development partners, multilateral agencies and others.

What data do I need to use HEAT?

You can carry out two types of assessment with HEAT, using 1) data from a single point in time, which is then compared to a hypothetical “comparison case” of “no walking or cycling”; or 2) a two case assessment, for example when assessing the impact “before and after” an intervention. You will need the following data for an assessment:

  • ­The average amount of walking or cycling in the study population needs to be entered. This can come from various sources, such as surveys, counts or scenario assumptions. The amount can be entered as duration, distance, trips, frequency, mode share or (for walking) steps.
  • The size of the assessed population needs to be estimated. This can be either pedestrians or cyclists only, or the general population.

In addition, HEAT requires further information, for which you can use the provided default values or local data, as available, including for example:

  • mortality rate
  • value of a statistical life
  • time period over which you wish average benefits to be calculated
  • a discount rate
  • cost of promoting cycling or walking

More information can be found here.

Where is HEAT applicable (countries, urban, rural)?

HEAT can be used at different geographical scales, including country, sub-national (i.e. “State” / “Province” and “County” / “District”) and city as well as sub-city-level. However, some default values are only available on national or city level (e.g. background air pollution levels, population data, mortality rates or crash risk data), thus users may need to enter their own data. HEAT can be used for urban or rural environments.

Can I use HEAT for my small, local scale project?

HEAT is based on studies that assessed health effects of cycling or walking of a certain regularity. HEAT is designed for regular, ideally habitual behaviour, such as cycling or walking for commuting, running errands or related to childcare, as well as regular leisure time activities. In the HEAT assessment, an annual average is derived. Thus, users should not use the HEAT for the evaluation of one-off events or competitions (such as single walking or cycling days etc.), since they are unlikely to reflect repeated, ideally habitual behaviour. So if you are confident that your project will have a lasting effect on the walking or cycling behaviour or your local population, you may use HEAT. It is suggested to run different calculations based on different assumptions, for example on the long-term effect of your project. Please also make sure that you use a mortality rate that reflects the age range of your local population as best as possible.

I am carrying out a project but we don’t have baseline data. Can I use HEAT?

You can carry out two types of assessment with HEAT, using 1) data from a single point in time, which is then compared to a hypothetical “comparison case” of “no walking or cycling”; or 2) a two case assessment, for example when assessing the impact “before and after” an intervention. So if you do not have baseline data, you can use HEAT to calculate the health benefits from the estimated or measured behaviour at the end of your project but you cannot compare it to the situation before the project started.

I am planning to participate in a walking event soon. Can I calculate my health benefits from going to this event with HEAT?

HEAT is to be applied for assessments on a population level: groups of people and not individuals. In addition, HEAT is designed for regular, ideally habitual behaviour, such as cycling or walking for commuting, running errands or related to childcare, as well as regular leisure time activities, not for one-off single-day events. So only use HEAT if you are confident that your project will have a lasting effect on the walking or cycling behaviour.

Are mortality rates from all countries provided?

The current version of HEAT has been adapted for global use. Therefore, the default values and drop-down options contain values from different countries. However, values can still be entered and adjusted by the user, in particular for the mortality rate and the value of statistical life. Indeed, for both these values it is important to use values that correctly represent the local situation, as they strongly influence the results.

Why is the age range for HEAT cycling and HEAT walking different?

HEAT is designed for regular, ideally habitual behaviour, such as cycling or walking for commuting, running errands or related to childcare, as well as regular leisure-time activities. The pensionable age is about 65 years in most countries. After retirement, physical activity behavior can change, in particular related to regular commuting. In addition, many mortality databases give mortality rates for up to 64-year-olds. The HEAT advisory group recommended that the applicable age range for HEAT for cycling is approximately 20–64 years. The relative risk used in HEAT, based on a meta-analysis of 7 cycling studies (see also here), was also considered to be applicable to this age range for cycling. For HEAT for walking, the relative risk estimate from the same meta-analysis including 14 studies is used (see also here) and the advisory group recommended that this relative risk shall be applicable for an age range of approximately 20–74 years, as walking behaviour (as well as e-biking, where also 20-74 years is provided for application of the cycling relative risk) seems to be more sustained with age than cycling.

Can I use HEAT for age ranges other than those recommended?

You may wish to use HEAT for slightly younger or older age groups than those recommended. However, if the age distribution in the assessed population is significantly different (i.e. much younger, much older), HEAT may over or underestimate the resulting benefits. In such cases, it is important to adjust the mortality rate, which depends strongly on the age of the assessed population. However, HEAT should not be applied to populations of children, very young adults, or older people, since the relative risk used by HEAT (see also here) does not include these age groups.

Which health outcomes are included?

Physical activity has beneficial effects on many aspects of morbidity, such as coronary heart disease, stroke, diabetes, some types of cancer, musculoskeletal health, energy balance and aspects of mental health (including anxiety and depression) and improving functional health among older people (1). ). From a public health viewpoint, these benefits materialize more rapidly than reductions in mortality. They can also be important in motivating individuals to walk and/or cycle, since people may be more likely to increase their physical activity to improve their immediate health and well-being than to live longer. Thus, including morbidity leads to more comprehensive economic appraisal of the health effects of transport interventions, and addressing morbidity has been identified as the single most important improvement to be made to HEAT in future revisions. In addition, the current evidence on morbidity, both for walking and for cycling, is more limited than that on mortality. Thus, including the impact of morbidity in economic appraisal leads to greater uncertainty.

Although the 2014 and 2016 consensus meetings considered options to include morbidity into HEAT (2,3), for the time being it was decided to focus only on all-cause mortality for HEAT for walking and for cycling. This method is likely to produce conservative estimates, since it does not account for disease-related benefits.

In a global context, additional considerations apply to using all-cause mortality. All-cause mortality is one of the most reliable health endpoints, with less variation in recording and reporting than cause-specific mortality, especially in low- and middle-income countries. Nevertheless, questions arise as to whether its use might unduly inflate impact estimates (such as because higher shares of infectious diseases less directly linked to physical activity are included in the default mortality rates provided). Although the HEAT advisory group acknowledged that all-cause mortality includes a substantial share of death unrelated to physical activity, such as communicable diseases and non-natural deaths (injuries), currently available evidence was not considered to be sufficient for a clear proposal to exclude certain causes of deaths (4).

In addition, noncommunicable diseases are an increasing problem in a global context: 77% of all deaths from noncommunicable diseases were in low- and middle-income countries (5). In the WHO African Region, noncommunicable disease–related deaths are projected to exceed deaths from communicable, maternal, perinatal and nutritional diseases combined by 2030 (6).

Additional research is warranted on how physical activity influences different causes of death and the potential risk of unduly inflating baseline mortality rates in some populations (for example, because of higher shares of injuries or violent deaths).

Sources:

1. WHO. WHO guidelines on physical activity and sedentary behaviour. Geneva: World Health Organization (https://apps.who.int/iris/handle/10665/336656, accessed 7 March 2022). 2020.

2. WHO Regional Office for Europe. Development of the health economic assessment tools (HEAT) for walking and cycling. Consensus workshop. Meeting background document. Bonn, Germany, 11–12 December 2014. Copenhagen: WHO Regional Office for Europe, 2014.

3. WHO Regional Office for Europe. Development of the health economic assessment tools (HEAT) for walking and cycling. 5th consensus meeting: meeting report. Copenhagen: WHO Regional Office for Europe, 2017.

4. WHO. Development of the health economic assessment tools (HEAT) for walking and cycling. 6th consensus group meeting: Meeting report. Geneva: World Health Organization, 2021.

5. WHO. Noncommunicable diseases: key facts [website]. Geneva: World Health Organization (https://www.who.int/news-room/fact-sheets/detail/noncommunicable-diseases, accessed 7 March 2022), 2021.

6. WHO Regional Office for Africa. Report on the status of major health risk factors for noncommunicable diseases: WHO African Region, 2015. Brazzaville: WHO Regional Office for Africa (https://apps.who.int/iris/handle/10665/253568, accessed 7 March 2022), 2015.

Why is PM2.5 used to assess the risk from air pollution in HEAT?

Air pollution is a complex mixture of different components. Particle pollution (also known as particulate matter) in the air includes a mixture of solids and liquid droplets. Some particles are emitted directly; others are formed in the atmosphere when other pollutants react. Particles come in a wide range of sizes. Those less than 10 micrometres in diameter (PM10) are so small that they can get into the lungs, potentially causing serious health problems. Even stronger health effects have been shown for particles with a diameter of less than 2.5 micrometres (PM2.5). Based on a large body of evidence, mainly from cohort studies, HEAT estimates the related health effects of ambient air pollution due to exposure to PM2.5. This is also relevant for low- and middle- income countries transitioning from predominant forms of household air pollution to higher levels of outdoor air pollution due to rapid urbanisation and mass motorisation.

In the absence of local ambient PM2.5 concentration measurements, an internationally accepted conversion factor of 0.60 was agreed (1) to use for HEAT to convert more widely available PM10 measurements into estimates of PM2.5 (more information on background values.)

Since evidence shows that PM2.5 is less directly related to emissions from road traffic than other pollutants, such as elemental carbon or black smoke, a sensitivity analysis was carried out (2) to assess the influence of the choice of pollutant on the HEAT results. Using elemental carbon, the estimates were very similar to those based on PM2.5.

For more information on air pollution see here.

Sources:

1. PM2.5, an indicator for fine particles. In: Air quality guidelines. Global update 2005. Particulate matter, ozone, nitrogen dioxide and sulfur dioxide. Copenhagen: WHO Regional Office for Europe, 2006: 40–1 (http://www.who.int/phe/health_topics/outdoorair/outdoorair_aqg/en, accessed 26 June 2015).

2. Development of the health economic assessment tools (HEAT) for walking and cycling. Consensus workshop. Bonn, Germany, 11–12 December 2014. Copenhagen: WHO Regional Office for Europe; 2015.

Can I change the relative risks used by HEAT?

No, it is not possible to change the relative risks used. The relative risks for HEAT cycling and HEAT walking (see also here) have been selected based on an extensive consensus finding process taking into account the best currently available evidence and are considered to be widely applicable.

Is the cycling speed / walking speed taken into account at all?

HEAT is meant to be applied for walking of at least moderate pace (i.e. about 5.3 km/hour / 3.3 miles/hour). This is in line with the walking speed of the studies in the meta-analysis (where available) to derive the relative risk for HEAT for walking (see also here) and equivalent to the minimum walking pace necessary to require an energy expenditure that is considered to be necessary for health benefits. For HEAT cycling, an average speed of 14km/h is used, based on an early study on cycling and mortality reductions (see link above). If the walking or cycling pace in the study population is unknown, these default speeds should be borne in mind as an underlying assumption.

What kind of costs are included in the “Value of a Statistical Life (VSL)” used in HEAT?

The value of a statistical life is derived with a method called “willingness to pay” (see also question “What is the “willingness to pay”?). According to economic theory, the willingness to pay comprises in particular immaterial costs (e.g. suffering) and the share of health costs paid directly by the victims. Thus, it includes the whole part of the costs to society borne by individuals but not the part borne by society (i.e. the rest of the health costs, administrative costs, lost production, costs for re-assignments, etc.). More information see here.

What is the “willingness to pay”?

The willingness to pay shows how much a representative sample of individuals is expressing to be willing to pay to secure a very small reduction in the risk of premature death. For example, how much would a representative sample of the population be willing to pay (in monetary terms) for a policy that would reduce their annual risk of dying prematurely from 3 in 10 000 to 2 in 10 000? This amount is then aggregated to reflect the value of preventing one entire premature death, i.e. a standard “value of a statistical life” (VSL). This is often used in transport appraisals. Please bear in mind that such assessments do not value an identified person’s life but refer to an average value of a “statistical life”. More information see here.

Is HEAT also available as an Excel spreadsheet?

No. HEAT is based on a complex, case-specific assessment scheme considering the particular characteristics of each assessment. This flexibility is not transferable to an Excel spreadsheet.