Adjusting input data
Depending on the type of assessment, HEAT offers the following options for adjusting input data. These options are available in the flexible and full user interfaces.
General adjustments of active travel data
Proportion excluded due to unrelated factors (“two case assessments” only)
When assessing the impact of an intervention, not all changes in walking or cycling will necessarily be caused by the intervention. For example, cycling may become more popular over time, or changes in fuel or public transport prices may influence people’s travel behaviour. Changes caused by such external factors should not be attributed to the intervention.
In practice, it is often difficult to separate the effects of the intervention from other influences. Use your best judgement to estimate the proportion of walking or cycling that should be excluded from the assessment because of these unrelated factors (for example, –30%).
The default setting is 0%.
Suggested values
Low range (0–30%)
Suitable when assessing comprehensive, long-term measures across a whole community, with no major external factors likely to have influenced walking or cycling. For example, there have been no major changes in fuel or public transport prices.
Mid-range (30–80%)
Suitable when other factors may have contributed to the observed changes in walking or cycling. For example, fuel prices increased substantially during the same period, or the intervention was implemented alongside other measures that could have affected walking or cycling.
High range (>80%)
Excluding more than 80% is generally appropriate only in unusual circumstances where there is strong evidence that most of the observed change was caused by an external factor. For example, an infrastructure project was implemented at the same time as area-wide reductions in speed limits that are likely to have had a much stronger effect on active travel.
Temporal and spatial adjustment
HEAT requires information on average active travel over a longer period, such as an annual average. However, walking and cycling can vary considerably depending on the season, weather and time of day.
Short-term counts or surveys may therefore not reflect the long-term average. For example, counts are often conducted in summer or autumn and during busy travel times. If your data come from a short-term count or survey, you can use this adjustment to account for possible differences (for example, +20% or –30%). Data from continuous counters can help determine whether such an adjustment is needed.
The location of a count or survey can also affect the results. People may walk or cycle more or less at the location where data were collected than on the facility or network as a whole, for example on a bike path or trail. You can use this adjustment to account for such differences (for example, +20% or –30%).
Data from several locations are usually helpful for estimating a spatial adjustment. However, in some cases, an informed estimate may be sufficient. A more precise adjustment would require a spatial modelling approach.
The default setting is 0%
Uptake time for active travel demand (“two case assessments” only)
Here you can specify how long it is expected to take for walking or cycling to reach the full level entered in the assessment.
For example, if a new footpath is expected to reach its full level of use after 5 years, enter 5 years. This allows HEAT to account for the gradual increase in walking or cycling after an intervention is implemented.
If you assume that the full level of walking or cycling is reached immediately, enter 0 years.
The default setting is 1 year.
Investment costs (“two case assessments” only)
Here you can enter the estimated cost of the intervention or investment that led to the additional walking or cycling being assessed.
HEAT compares these costs with the estimated economic value of the health and other effects and calculates a benefit–cost ratio.
Adjustment options to characterize the assessed active travel
For some assessments, HEAT asks a few additional questions to improve the calculations. HEAT only shows the questions that are relevant to the selected assessment.
The first questions focus on what happened to the trips in the reference case: did they remain the same, change route, or replace trips by another mode? Specifically, HEAT asks about the proportion of new trips, reassigned trips and shifted trips.
Proportion of new trips (“two case assessments, carbon” only)
New trips are trips that did not take place in the reference case. They are not trips shifted from another mode or moved to a different route.
For carbon assessments where no information on motorized travel is available, this information helps HEAT estimate emissions from starting a vehicle, which depend on the number of trips made by walking or cycling each year. See operational emissions.
The default setting is 0%.
Proportion of reassigned trips (“two case assessments, sub-city level” only)
Reassigned trips are trips that use a different route because of new infrastructure, such as a new footpath or cycling route. They do not represent additional walking or cycling and are therefore excluded from the assessment.
The proportion of reassigned trips usually needs to be estimated. A survey conducted before the new infrastructure was built can provide more reliable information. For example, people could be asked whether they previously used a different route for the same trip or already used the same mode for this type of trip.
The proportion may be higher for attractive new facilities, such as a high-quality cycling route, or facilities that provide an important connection, such as a bridge. It may be lower for less attractive or less important improvements, such as a short section of pavement.
This adjustment is only used for sub-city assessments, because trips cannot be reassigned at the country or city level.
The default setting is 0%.
Proportion of trips shifted from another mode (“single case assessments, carbon” only)
Shifted trips are walking or cycling trips that replace a trip made by another mode, such as car or public transport.
First, enter the estimated total proportion of walking or cycling trips that replaced another mode (for example, 80%).
The default setting is 0%.
You can then specify which modes these trips replaced. The percentages for the different modes must add up to no more than 100%.
See carbon emissions for more information.
The sliders use default values if no adjustments are made.
Additional adjustment options
Additional questions allow further adjusting the assessed walking and cycling, including on motorized traffic, which affects both carbon emissions and exposure to air pollution, on changes in road crash risk; and on activity substitution, where walking or cycling replaces another type of physical activity.
Proportion of active travel done “in traffic” (“air pollution assessments” only)
his question asks what proportion of walking or cycling in the reference case takes place on or near roads with motorized traffic, rather than in places away from major roads, such as parks.
HEAT uses this information to estimate the level of air pollution people are exposed to while walking or cycling. See more information here.
The default setting is 50%.
Proportion of travel done “for transport” (“air pollution” and “carbon assessments” only)
This question asks what proportion of the walking or cycling entered is for transport rather than for recreation:
- Transport-related trips are made to get somewhere for a specific purpose, such as going to work, shopping, visiting friends or playing tennis. These trips are assumed to replace another mode of transport and therefore to take place in environments with higher air pollution levels.
- Recreational trips are made mainly for exercise or leisure. These trips are assumed to replace time spent at home, where background air pollution levels apply.
Please enter the proportion of walking or cycling that is for transport purposes.
For more information on air pollution assessments, see here.
For carbon assessments, HEAT only considers active travel for transport purposes, assuming that these trips replace other modes of transport. Recreational trips are assumed not to replace other transport and are therefore not included.
For more information on carbon emissions assessments, see here.
Traffic conditions (“carbon assessments” only)
For carbon assessments, you can specify the typical traffic conditions at the times when people walk or cycle. Traffic conditions affect vehicle emissions and therefore the estimated carbon savings from replacing motorized travel.
Choose the option that best describes the situation:
- European average: average conditions for urban or rural areas in Europe.
- Free flow: little or no congestion (average traffic speed: 45 km/h).
- Some peak-time congestion: congestion during busy periods, such as the morning commute, school run or afternoon commute (average speed: 35 km/h).
- Heavy congestion: heavy congestion on most days (average speed: 20 km/h).
The default setting is global urban average.
Change in crash risk (“two case assessments, crashes” only)
Road crash risk for people walking or cycling can change for several reasons, including changes in the amount of walking or cycling and improvements to infrastructure.
Here you can enter the percentage change in crash risk between the reference and comparison cases. For example, enter a reduction if you expect the intervention to make walking or cycling safer.
If you leave this field blank, HEAT assumes that the crash risk is the same in both cases.
The default setting is 0%.
Substitution effect (“two case assessments, physical activity” only)
Some of the walking or cycling included in the assessment may replace other physical activity, such as sport or exercise that people previously did in their leisure time.
This activity does not represent an overall increase in physical activity. The proportion that replaces other physical activity should therefore be excluded from the assessment.
The default setting is 0%.