Air pollution calculation
A method used for comparative risk assessment of air pollution and modes of transport (1,2) was agreed to serve as basis for assessing the air pollution effects on cyclists and pedestrians in HEAT (3,4,5). This method uses PM2.5 (particulate matter with a diameter of less than 2.5 micrometres, see also here) as the air pollution measure, based on background PM2.5 concentrations. Based on the selected country and/or city, HEAT will propose a PM2.5 concentration retrieved from the WHO Global Urban Ambient Air Pollution Database (city values).
HEAT estimates the health effects of air pollution exposure associated with walking and cycling using an established comparative risk assessment approach (1,2,3,4,5). The tool uses PM2.5 (fine particulate matter) as the measure of air pollution.
Air pollution levels
When a country and/or city is selected, HEAT provides a background PM2.5 concentration based on data from the WHO Global Urban Ambient Air Pollution Database for cities or the WHO Global Health Observatory for countries (7). Users can review and, if appropriate, replace this value with a local estimate. Where PM2.5 data are not available, HEAT allows PM2.5 to be estimated from PM10 using an internationally accepted conversion factor of 0.6 (4,8).
The actual exposure while walking or cycling depends on where the activity takes place. HEAT therefore adjusts the background concentration to reflect the environment in which people are travelling and the amount of air they breathe during the activity.
How exposure is calculated
HEAT estimates the amount of PM2.5 inhaled during walking, cycling or e-biking based on:
- the PM2.5 concentration in the relevant environment;
- the time spent walking or cycling; and
- the ventilation rate, that is, the amount of air breathed per hour during the activity.
HEAT uses ventilation rates of 1.37 m³/hour for walking, 2.55 m³/hour for cycling and 2.1 m³/hour for e-biking (3,4). The resulting intake is combined with exposure during the rest of the day to estimate the overall change in exposure between the reference and comparison cases.
Two factors determine the exposure
HEAT considers two aspects of walking and cycling when estimating the change in air pollution exposure:
1. Where the walking or cycling takes place
The tool distinguishes between:
- on or near roads with motorized traffic: the PM2.5 concentration is assumed to be higher than the background concentration, using mode-specific conversion factors.
- in parks or away from roads with motorized traffic: the PM2.5 concentration is assumed to be equal to the background concentration.
The conversion factors are 2.0 for cycling and e-biking and 1.6 for walking, based on a review of studies comparing PM2.5 exposure across different travel modes (9).
2. Why people are walking or cycling
The main purpose of the activity also determines the comparison case used by HEAT:
- leisure: the comparison is with staying at home, where the PM2.5 concentration is assumed to equal the background concentration.
- commuting: the comparison is with travelling by car, where the PM2.5 concentration is assumed to be higher than the background concentration.
For both comparison cases, HEAT uses a ventilation rate of 0.61 m³/hour (3,4). For car travel, the PM2.5 concentration is estimated using a conversion factor of 2.5 compared with background levels. This factor is an approximation based on the studies included in the review of air pollution exposure in different travel modes (9).
Estimating health effects
HEAT uses evidence on the relationship between long-term PM2.5 exposure and mortality. The systematic review supporting the WHO Air Quality Guidelines found a relative risk of 1.08 (95% CI 1.06–1.09) for all-cause mortality for each additional 10 µg/m³ of PM2.5 (4).
As with the health effects of physical activity, the effects of air pollution are assumed to build up over time. HEAT uses a five-year period, with 20% of the full effect added each year, based on expert consensus.
Scope and limitations
Research suggests that the relationship between PM2.5 exposure and health risks may become less steep at higher pollution levels. However, the increase in air pollution exposure caused by walking or cycling is generally small compared with exposure during the rest of the day (3,5,10,11). HEAT therefore uses a linear relationship between PM2.5 exposure and mortality risk within the range relevant to the tool.
To avoid overestimating health risks at very high pollution levels, HEAT applies a maximum PM2.5 concentration of 100 µg/m³ when calculating health effects. No lower limit is applied, as evidence indicates that health effects can occur even at low levels of air pollution (13).
HEAT estimates the air pollution effects on people who walk or cycle. It does not include the potentially substantial health benefits for the wider population that could result from reducing overall air pollution when motorized travel is replaced by walking or cycling (1).
For details on the air pollution module of HEAT, see the Methods and user guide booklet (chapter 3.11 Air pollution assessment in HEAT).
Relative risk for air pollution
HEAT uses a relative risk estimate from a meta-analysis of 107 cohort studies conducted in countries across Europe, North America, Asia and Oceania, including Canada, China, France, Germany, Israel, Italy, Japan, New Zealand, Norway, the Netherlands, South Korea, Sweden, Taiwan, the United Kingdom and the United States (1).
The meta-analysis estimated the risk of death from any cause associated with long-term exposure to PM2.5 (particulate matter with a diameter of less than 2.5 micrometres (2)). For each additional 10 µg/m³ of PM2.5, the relative risk was 1.08 (95% CI 1.04–1.09). In simple terms, this means that long-term exposure to PM2.5 levels that are 10 µg/m³ higher is associated with an 8% higher risk of death, assuming other relevant characteristics are comparable.
The study found very similar estimates for the European, Americas and Western Pacific regions. It also found little evidence that the association differed between women and men. Studies of predominantly older populations showed somewhat smaller relative risks, but the difference was not statistically significant (1).
Sources:
1. Chen J and Hoek G. Long-term exposure to PM and all-cause and cause-specific mortality: A systematic review and meta-analysis. Environment International 2020 (143): 105974. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.envint.2020.105974
2. PM2.5, an indicator for fine particles. In: Air quality guidelines. Global update 2005. Particulate matter, ozone, nitrogen dioxide and sulfur dioxide. Copenhagen: WHO Regional Office for Europe, 2006: 40–1 http://www.euro.who.int/__data/assets/pdf_file/0010/263629/WHO-Expert-Meeting-Methods-and-tools-for-assessing-the-health-risks-of-air-pollution-at-local,-national-and-international-level.pdf?ua=1, accessed 10 October 2017).
Combining physical activity and air pollution exposure
The published relative risks for mortality and physical activity from walking and cycling used by HEAT are taken from studies in settings in which participants were exposed to (different levels of) air pollution. As such, the relative risks for physical activity include a small population-average degree of influence of air pollution while walking or cycling. When HEAT users select solely assessing the effects of physical activity, this is not specifically adjusted for, implicitly assuming that air pollution levels are comparable between the assessed setting and the settings in which the studies were conducted.
However, if the user selects both the physical activity and the air pollution assessment, then HEAT adjusts the relative risk for physical activity benefits from walking and cycling to exclude the effects of air pollution, using relative risk estimates adjusted to what they would be if the physical activity studies had been conducted in non-polluted environments. The effects of the additional air pollution exposure from walking or cycling are calculated separately (and shown in the detailed HEAT results).
To derive the adjusted relative risks, the exposure to air pollution (PM2.5) in each of the cycling and walking study settings was estimated using international databases and assuming a 50% higher historical exposure to consider the general improvement of air pollution between the time the underlying studies were conducted (between 1964 and the early 2000s) and the year 2011 for which air pollution exposure was available (3). The effect of this exposure while walking or cycling on the original relative risks from the physical activity studies (4) was calculated, using a previously published exposure response function between PM 2.5 and all-cause mortality (5) (almost identical to the currently used relative risk in HEAT), default inhalation rates and the published durations of exposure (3).
Overview of the relative risks used in physical activity assessments
Cycling
- Unadjusted: RR = 0.903 (0.866-0.943)
- Adjusted for air pollution (new): RR = 0.899 (0.861-0.939)
Walking
- Unadjusted: RR = 0.886 (0.806-0.973)
- Adjusted for air pollution (new): RR = 0.883 (0.803-0.970).
Note that the vice versa argument could be made for the influence of active travel on the published relative risks of air pollution from studies in which subjects are engaged in walking or cycling. It is fair to assume that this influence would be negligible because of the small contribution of the additional inhaled dose of air pollution while walking or cycling to the total exposure of the entire study population.
Sources:
1. Chen J and Hoek G. Long-term exposure to PM and all-cause and cause-specific mortality: A systematic review and meta-analysis. Environment International 2020 (143): 105974. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.envint.2020.105974
2. PM2.5, an indicator for fine particles. In: Air quality guidelines. Global update 2005. Particulate matter, ozone, nitrogen dioxide and sulfur dioxide. Copenhagen: WHO Regional Office for Europe, 2006: 40–1 http://www.euro.who.int/__data/assets/pdf_file/0010/263629/WHO-Expert-Meeting-Methods-and-tools-for-assessing-the-health-risks-of-air-pollution-at-local,-national-and-international-level.pdf?ua=1, accessed 10 October 2017).
3. Development of the Health economic assessment tools (HEAT) for walking and cycling: Consensus workshop. Meeting background document. Bonn, Germany, 11-12 December 2014. Copenhagen: WHO Regional Office for Europe; 2014.
4. Kelly P et al. Systematic review and meta-analysis of reduction in all-cause mortality from walking and cycling and shape of dose response relationship. 2014, International Journal of Behavioral Nutrition and Physical Activity (11):132 (https://doi.org/10.1186/s12966-014-0132-x, accessed 31 August 2017).
5. Hoek G et al. Long-term air pollution exposure and cardio-respiratory mortality: a review. Environ Health 2013 (12):43. http://www.ehjournal.net/content/12/1/4, accessed 1 November 2021.
Combining physical activity and air pollution exposure
Walking and cycling provide health benefits through physical activity, but they may also increase exposure to air pollution when people travel in polluted environments. When both physical activity and air pollution are assessed in HEAT, it is important to avoid counting the effects of air pollution twice.
The influence of walking or cycling on the relative risks for air pollution is likely to be small, because the additional dose of air pollution inhaled while walking or cycling represents only a small part of a person’s total exposure over time. Conversely, some studies on the health benefits of walking and cycling were conducted in environments with different levels of air pollution. One of the studies included in the HEAT analysis, for example, was carried out in China (1), where air pollution levels were considerably higher than in the other study settings. The reductions in premature mortality associated with regular walking and cycling were nevertheless comparable to those found in studies conducted in less polluted environments (2).
If the user selects both the physical activity and the air pollution assessment, HEAT uses adjusted relative risks for physical activity to remove the influence of air pollution. In other words, the health benefits of walking and cycling are estimated as if the underlying studies had been conducted in environments without air pollution.
HEAT then calculates the health effects of the additional air pollution exposure from walking or cycling separately. These results are shown in the detailed output of the tool.
The overall estimate therefore combines:
- the health benefits of physical activity; and
- the health risks related to additional air pollution exposure.
This approach provides an estimate of the net health impact of walking and cycling while avoiding double counting of air pollution effects.
Further details on how the adjusted relative risks were derived can be found in the Methods and user guide booklet (chapter 3.11.3 Combining physical activity and air pollution exposure).
Sources:
1. Matthews CE. et al. Influence of exercise, walking, cycling, and overall nonexercise physical activity on mortality in Chinese women. 2007, American Journal of Epidemiology 165(12):1343-50. doi: 10.1093/aje/kwm088 (accessed 18 October 2021).
2. Kelly P et al. Systematic review and meta-analysis of reduction in all-cause mortality from walking and cycling and shape of dose response relationship. 2014, International Journal of Behavioral Nutrition and Physical Activity (11):132 (https://doi.org/10.1186/s12966-014-0132-x, accessed 31 August 2017).
Sources:
1. de Hartog JJ et al. Do the health benefits of cycling outweigh the risks? Environ Health Perspect. 2010;118:1109–16.
2. Rojas-Rueda D et al. The health risks and benefits of cycling in urban environments compared with car use: health impact assessment study. BMJ. 2011;343:d4521.
3. Rojas-Rueda D, Nieuwenhuijsen M. Adjustment of risk estimates of physical activity and mortality by the impact of air pollution (particulate matter of less than 2.5 µm). Barcelona: Centre for Research in Environmental Epidemiology (CREAL); 2014.
4. Chen J and Hoek G. Long-term exposure to PM and all-cause and cause-specific mortality: A systematic review and meta-analysis. Environment International 2020 (143): 105974. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.envint.2020.105974
5. Development of the health economic assessment tools (HEAT) for walking and cycling. Consensus workshop. Bonn, Germany, 11–12 December 2014. Copenhagen: WHO Regional Office for Europe; 2015.
6. World Health Organization. WHO Global Urban Ambient Air Pollution Database (http://www.who.int/phe/health_topics/outdoorair/databases/cities/en/), accessed 14 September 2017.
7. World Health Organization. WHO Global Health Observatory data repository, Exposure Country Average 2014. (http://apps.who.int/gho/data/view.main.SDGPM25116v?lang=en), accessed 15 September 2017.
8. PM2.5, an indicator for fine particles. In: Air quality guidelines. Global update 2005. Particulate matter, ozone, nitrogen dioxide and sulfur dioxide. Copenhagen: WHO Regional Office for Europe, 2006: 40–1 (http://www.who.int/phe/health_topics/outdoorair/outdoorair_aqg/en, accessed 26 June 2015).
9. De Nazelle et al. Comparison of air pollution exposures in active vs. passive travel modes in European cities: A quantitative review. Environment International 2017 (99): 151-160 (Appendix C). (http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0160412016304585?via%3Dihub, accessed 31 August 2017).
10. Andersen ZJ et al. A Study of the Combined Effects of Physical Activity and Air Pollution on Mortality in Elderly Urban Residents: The Danish Diet, Cancer, and Health Cohort. Environ Health Perspect 2015 (123):557–563; http://dx.doi.org/10.1289/ehp.1408698
11. WHO. Personal Interventions and Risk Communication on Air Pollution. 2020. Summary report of a WHO Expert Consultation, 12–14 February 2019, Geneva, Switzerland. Geneva: World Health Organization.
12. Cohen A et al. Urban air pollution. In: Ezzati M, Lopez AD, Rodgers A, Murray CJL, editors. Comparative quantification of health risks: global and regional burden of disease attribution to selected major risk factors. Volume 1. Geneva: World Health Organization; 2004:1353–434. (http://www.who.int/healthinfo/global_burden_disease/cra/en, accessed 31 August 2017).
13. World Health Organization. Ambient air pollution data. (https://www.who.int/data/gho/data/themes/air-pollution/ambient-air-pollution), accessed 7 November 2021.
14. Di Q et al. Air Pollution and Mortality in the Medicare Population. N Engl J Med 2017 (376):2513-2522. DOI: 10.1056/NEJMoa1702747.